Celtic’s decision to sanction Arne Engels’ £22 million move to West Ham United less than 24 hours after unveiling Mika Baur is a baffling piece of short-termism that undermines the club’s stated ambition to compete in the Champions League.
While the fee is significant and the player’s desire to move south of the border was clear, the timing - on the eve of the two-legged play-off against LASK - exposes a board prioritising the balancing of the books over sporting ambition.
Ambition, Investment, and the Baur Signal
Less than 24 hours ago, the signing of 22-year-old German midfielder Mika Baur from Paderborn for up to £8 million was framed as a statement of intent. The narrative was compelling that Celtic were no longer content to merely stay one step ahead of Rangers; they were building a squad capable of qualifying for the Champions League and testing themselves against Europe’s elite. Baur’s arrival, alongside Camilo Duran, Kasper Høgh, and Haissem Hassan, suggested a coherent plan to refresh the spine of the team while retaining much of its core. Even if some of them wanted away.
Yet, within hours of Baur’s unveiling, the club approved the sale of Arne Engels, a key first-team midfielder, to West Ham United for £22 million plus add-ons. The optics are evident once again from Celtic - a “statement signing” immediately followed by the departure of a proven performer ahead of the most important fixtures of the early season.
The Case for Patience: Why the Board Held All the Cards
There is no denying that Engels was keen on a move to England. West Ham had submitted multiple bids, with the player’s personal terms reportedly agreed well in advance. But Celtic were not in a position of financial desperation to accept the bid. The club’s accounts, even after the summer spending, did not require another immediate sale following the departure of Daizen Maeda to Ipswich Town.
More importantly, the club held all the leverage. West Ham’s interest was not going to vanish if the deal concluded after the LASK ties. Selling key players before the Champions League play-off is risky and undermines the squad’s chances of success - as Celtic found out to our cost last season. The board could have waited until the qualifiers were complete, thanked Engels for his services, and wished him well at his new club - without jeopardising the team’s European campaign.
The Sporting Cost: Weakening the Midfield on the Eve of Battle
Let’s get this straight, Engels was not a fringe player. He isn’t someone we can sell and not see the gap left by his departure. Since his £11 million arrival from FC Augsburg in summer 2024, he has made 93 appearances and scored 17 goals, becoming a mainstay in Celtic’s midfield. His departure leaves a void that cannot simply be filled by an unproven prospect in Baur, no matter how promising.
Mika Baur may yet prove to be a top-drawer midfielder at Celtic - even better than Engels in the long term. But no credible and ambitious organisation replaces a key midfielder with an unknown prospect on the eve of their biggest game of the season.
The Financial Logic vs. Sporting Reality
The board’s rationale is clear, £22 million is a significant fee, and it helps offset the £30.6 million spent on four new signings this summer - along with the £8 million sale of Daizen Maeda earlier in the window. But this logic ignores the financial stakes of the Champions League. Qualification brings not only prestige but also substantial revenue - far exceeding the £22 million that Celtic have secured from the Hammers.
If Celtic are knocked out of the Champions League because the midfield is weaker without Engels, the board’s decision will be viewed as a catastrophic misjudgement. The short-term financial gain pales in comparison to the long-term sporting and financial consequences of missing out on Europe’s premier competition.
A Further Pattern of Mismanagement
This is not the first time Celtic’s board has been accused of prioritising finances over sporting success and it won’t be the last. The pattern is concerning - invest in new talent, then sell established performers before crucial fixtures to balance the books.
The timing of Engels’ sale - less than 24 hours after Baur’s unveiling - suggests a lack of strategic coherence. If the board truly believes in the club’s Champions League ambitions, why weaken the squad before the qualifiers? The decision smacks of panic rather than planning.
Trust Eroded
For the fans, the message is clear that the board’s ambitions do not align with their own. Supporters want to see Celtic compete in the Champions League, not just qualify for it.
The board may argue that they had no choice, that Engels’ desire to move and West Ham’s persistence forced their hand. But the evidence suggests otherwise. Celtic could have waited. They should have waited. The fact that they did not speaks volumes about their priorities.
The Path Forward: Engels Replacement & Strategic Clarity
The damage is done. Engels has reportedly passed his medical in London, and West Ham are preparing to announce their latest signing. The focus must now shift to finding further additions to strengthen a side that is still lacking in numbers.
Celtic need to act swiftly in the transfer market to secure a replacement midfielder. Names like Gvidas Gineitis, Miguel Chaiwa, Niko Sigur, and Ermin Mahmic have been mentioned, but the club must ensure that any new signing is ready to contribute immediately.
More importantly, the board must provide clarity on their strategic vision. Are Celtic a selling club, or a competing club? The two are not mutually exclusive, but the timing of sales matters. If the board truly believes in the club’s Champions League ambitions, they must demonstrate it through their actions - not just their words after the fact.
The Bottom Line
Arne Engels’ sale to West Ham United is a £22 million gamble that could risk Celtic’s Champions League spot. The board’s decision to sanction the move before the LASK ties is a clear mismanagement of the club’s sporting and financial interests.
The fans deserve better. The manager deserves better. The players deserve better. And the club’s ambitions deserve better. If Celtic are to compete in the Champions League, they must start by competing in the transfer market with the same ambition they claim to possess. Anything less is a betrayal of their roles as custodians of the club.
The board’s next moves will determine whether this is a temporary misstep this season or a continued pattern of mismanagement that we have come to see over the years.
As for Arne Engels, I wish him well at West Ham. He still had a huge amount to offer Celtic and could have stayed on a further year to develop further with added experience in the Champions League - but the lure of football in England along with the wages on offer is hard to resist and who can blame the 22 year old.
The Lask game will be 50-50 I think, because our midfield is weak at the moment.
I hate having the second leg away from home, how is it Celtic always have to play the second leg away in Europe it seems, nearly every time.?
I'm still pretty confident we can put the tie to bed after the first leg.
Without being devil's advocate, the Chermiti injury obviously swayed the board and who could blame them?
LASK are not any great shakes (hopefully), we'll have Calmac, the Ox, MacCowan, Nygren and if he can hit the pitch running Baur.
If our board are going to buy anyone else let it be Sigur, apparently he can play RB, LB and DM.
Do we want the huns to get through the UECL? If they dont they get midweek off, but even the pittance of money would be welcome to them but I'd rather they had at least 6 games on a Thursday which would mean they play league games on Sundays.